Author Topic: Needham Market withdraw from FA Trophy  (Read 3487 times)

leicester pilgrim

  • Veteran Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 992
    • View Profile
Needham Market withdraw from FA Trophy
« on: December 17, 2018, 10:15:36 PM »
Needham Market were due to have played away at Weymouth in the FA Trophy on Saturday. It appears they travelled down to Weymouth, but the match was postponed relatively late due to a waterlogged pitch.

The FA have ruled that the match has to be replayed tomorrow night (Tuesday). Because of the distance involved, the Needham players coach would need to leave at 11am and wouldn't get home until around 5am on Wednesday morning. Their players are all part time, and the club feels it is unreasonable to expect them to book two days holiday so close to Christmas. It is unfair on the players' employers as well as the players. Given weather forecasts, Needham aren't confident that the game would even go ahead on Tuesday.

Needham have asked the FA to arrange the replay for a Saturday between now and the next round, but the FA have refused. In response, Needham have issued a statement that they now wish to pull out of this season's FA Trophy, handing a bye to Weymouth into the next round. It also means Needham can't recover any of the costs from their aborted coach trip on Saturday.

What a mess, and you have to feel sorry for Needham in all of this.

Could the FA Trophy be restructured?

Why not start the competion earlier in the season and then spread the rounds out more?

Why not then have a window either side of the Christmas period when clubs play league matches only? Reduced travel during bad weather periods for clubs like Needham. Plus reduced pressures on groundsmen to get pitches playable for extra unscheduled matches during the winter.

Why not have a 10 day gap between initial round dates and replay dates? Recognise that players are often part time and give them more chance of getting time off work. Same applies to supporters.

 I'm sure the competition used to be more spaced out than it is now.

chris b

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 359
    • View Profile
Re: Needham Market withdraw from FA Trophy
« Reply #1 on: December 17, 2018, 11:00:36 PM »
The final was moved to March for a few years - I think to encourage the teams at the top end of the Conference to take it more seriously, getting it out of the way before the playoffs. There's a two month gap between the semi finals and the final at the moment - I guess for the same reason?

Weymouth will have to go to Workington or Ramsbottom in the next round. Presumably they'll pass Stockport heading to Truro at some point on the M6!

youngchubby69

  • Guest
Re: Needham Market withdraw from FA Trophy
« Reply #2 on: December 18, 2018, 07:08:15 AM »
The FA have and it's rules, we all know about them hey!!
They have no idea how a part time club is run and the strain it puts on the players having to juggle their work and family commitments around playing.
The extremely wealthy FA are only interested in taking money from all football clubs around the country.
Yes they do invest money back in to clubs, but not very much in comparison to what they get in.


BostonGoals

  • Veteran Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 845
    • View Profile
Re: Needham Market withdraw from FA Trophy
« Reply #3 on: December 18, 2018, 08:04:13 AM »
Weymouth to Workington! About 7 hours each way? Not going to try and have a replay of that on a midweek otherwise will be Workington pulling out this time.

green hats mate

  • Veteran Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 4695
    • View Profile
Re: Needham Market withdraw from FA Trophy
« Reply #4 on: December 18, 2018, 09:51:19 AM »
Needham Market were due to have played away at Weymouth in the FA Trophy on Saturday. It appears they travelled down to Weymouth, but the match was postponed relatively late due to a waterlogged pitch.

The FA have ruled that the match has to be replayed tomorrow night (Tuesday). Because of the distance involved, the Needham players coach would need to leave at 11am and wouldn't get home until around 5am on Wednesday morning. Their players are all part time, and the club feels it is unreasonable to expect them to book two days holiday so close to Christmas. It is unfair on the players' employers as well as the players. Given weather forecasts, Needham aren't confident that the game would even go ahead on Tuesday.

Needham have asked the FA to arrange the replay for a Saturday between now and the next round, but the FA have refused. In response, Needham have issued a statement that they now wish to pull out of this season's FA Trophy, handing a bye to Weymouth into the next round. It also means Needham can't recover any of the costs from their aborted coach trip on Saturday.

What a mess, and you have to feel sorry for Needham in all of this.

Could the FA Trophy be restructured?

Why not start the competion earlier in the season and then spread the rounds out more?

Why not then have a window either side of the Christmas period when clubs play league matches only? Reduced travel during bad weather periods for clubs like Needham. Plus reduced pressures on groundsmen to get pitches playable for extra unscheduled matches during the winter.

Why not have a 10 day gap between initial round dates and replay dates? Recognise that players are often part time and give them more chance of getting time off work. Same applies to supporters.

 I'm sure the competition used to be more spaced out than it is now.

On this particular match the F A was sadly lacking in flexibility ,  fairness , and common sense .

youngchubby69

  • Guest
Re: Needham Market withdraw from FA Trophy
« Reply #5 on: December 18, 2018, 10:11:38 AM »
Needham Market were due to have played away at Weymouth in the FA Trophy on Saturday. It appears they travelled down to Weymouth, but the match was postponed relatively late due to a waterlogged pitch.

The FA have ruled that the match has to be replayed tomorrow night (Tuesday). Because of the distance involved, the Needham players coach would need to leave at 11am and wouldn't get home until around 5am on Wednesday morning. Their players are all part time, and the club feels it is unreasonable to expect them to book two days holiday so close to Christmas. It is unfair on the players' employers as well as the players. Given weather forecasts, Needham aren't confident that the game would even go ahead on Tuesday.

Needham have asked the FA to arrange the replay for a Saturday between now and the next round, but the FA have refused. In response, Needham have issued a statement that they now wish to pull out of this season's FA Trophy, handing a bye to Weymouth into the next round. It also means Needham can't recover any of the costs from their aborted coach trip on Saturday.

What a mess, and you have to feel sorry for Needham in all of this.

Could the FA Trophy be restructured?

Why not start the competion earlier in the season and then spread the rounds out more?

Why not then have a window either side of the Christmas period when clubs play league matches only? Reduced travel during bad weather periods for clubs like Needham. Plus reduced pressures on groundsmen to get pitches playable for extra unscheduled matches during the winter.

Why not have a 10 day gap between initial round dates and replay dates? Recognise that players are often part time and give them more chance of getting time off work. Same applies to supporters.

 I'm sure the competition used to be more spaced out than it is now.

On this particular match the F A was sadly lacking in flexibility ,  fairness , and common sense .
Sadly that's a common practice with the FA