I'm not so sure it's that simple Chris? The probability must be swayed by who you are and the size of the pool you're drawing from. Example: if you're first game is against AC Fylde then the probability of you're next game being alphabetical is 1 or certainty. However, if you're first game is against Worcester then the probability becomes 0. As teams cannot play themselves, then it follows that the probability of alphabetical games is higher for Worcester than AC Fylde?
However.....whilst I was typing I've changed my mind to agree with you as if there were only three teams in the league then the probability would always be 0.5.....or 1/2! For AFC Fylde, the second alphabetical club becomes the certainty first game. Doh!