A few years ago my son asked me exactly that question. I go back to the mid 70's, so I ended up with 22 players, a squad rather than a team. I did pick some players based on their career credentials, not just Pilgrims ones, but here are those that have stuck in my mind...
McKenna, Bastock, Adamson, Casey, Mann, Jelleyman, Thompson, Hardy, Fee, Ellender, Costello, Noble, Hartford, Gascoigne, Mike Marsh, Ross, Hamill, Gilbert, Cook, Kirk, Gary Jones, Lumby.